Now, a team of researchers report in the May 14 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) that they have an answer.* Based on the largest and most definitive study ever to examine this issue, the scientists found that people who have unusual moles are indeed at increased risk for melanoma. They discovered, in fact, that about half of the 738 people with melanoma in the study had numerous, clearly defined abnormal moles on their bodies. The investigators noted that the risk was greatest in people who also have extremely fair skin and heavy freckling, a sign of excessive sun exposure.
The scientists also report a strong risk of melanoma in people age 50 and older who had many abnormal moles on their bodies. Because people stop developing or lose moles by middle age, the investigators said this finding suggests a possible profile of middle-aged and older people who are most likely to develop melanoma.
Given the strength of their data, the researchers indicated that doctors might want to routinely evaluate the moles and freckling patterns of their patients, especially those with fair complexions. They said this would be an efficient and inexpensive way to identify people who should limit their time in the sun and receive regular testing for skin cancer. "Melanoma rates are rising throughout the world," said Margaret Tucker, M.D., a scientist at the National Cancer Institute and the lead author of the paper. "This study provides a basic profile of people who are at most risk of developing melanoma, opening the door for earlier prevention and detection strategies."
An estimated one out of every 10 Americans has at least one abnormal mole, or dysplastic nevus (plural - dysplastic nevi). These moles are larger than common moles, with borders that are irregular and poorly defined. Dysplastic nevi also vary in color, ranging from tan to dark brown shades on a pink background.
The link between dysplastic moles and melanoma was first reported in the 1970s when scientists observed that members of a melanoma-prone family had numerous large, abnormal moles on their bodies. By the early 1980s, researchers also noted that some people without any family history of melanoma had dysplastic nevi, raising the question of whether these individuals are at increased risk for skin cancer.
Subsequent work has largely confirmed this association. In fact, several small studies have suggested that dysplastic nevi could account for 29 percent to 49 percent of nonfamilial melanoma. Other studies have indicated that people who have numerous abnormal moles could have as great as a sevenfold increased risk for melanoma.
However, the subject has remained controversial. Some investigators have stated that the definition of dysplastic nevi in several studies has been too imprecise, subject to bias, and generally inconclusive on the issue of melanoma risk. They have said that without standard criteria to diagnose dysplastic nevi, both in the clinic and under the microscope, clinicians would be hard pressed to differentiate between normal and dysplastic moles.
The article published this week in JAMA should help to settle the controversy. The study reported in the journal involved nearly 1,800 people -- 738 people diagnosed with melanoma and 1,030 people without the disease -- who were examined primarily at the Melanoma Clinic of the University of California at San Francisco and the Pigmented Lesion Clinic of the University of Pennsylvania, Pa. All participants agreed to an interview, a complete skin examination, photography of their most atypical moles, and possibly a biopsy of their most unusual mole.
In one of the study's key findings, Tucker et al. report that clinicians independently agreed almost nine out of 10 times on whether a mole was normal or dysplastic. The study defined dysplastic nevi as being flat or partly flat, 5 millimeters or larger, and showing two or more of the following characteristics: variable pigmentation, asymmetric outline, and indistinct borders. "This study adds strong evidence to what several other smaller studies have already demonstrated, " said Tucker. "By scrupulously adhering to recognized diagnostic criteria, experienced clinicians will agree in most cases that a mole is dysplastic."
The researchers also found they could correlate the number and type of moles, both normal and abnormal, on a person's body with their risk of developing melanoma. For those with unusually high numbers of normal, but no abnormal, moles, the researchers calculated a twofold increased risk for melanoma. For those with numerous small and large normal moles, the risk for melanoma was four times higher than normal.
The risk associated with clearly defined dysplastic moles was much higher. The scientists estimated that individuals with a single dysplastic mole on their bodies have a twofold risk of developing melanoma. The risk rises to 14-fold in those with 10 or more abnormal moles.
"The fact that we could make this correlation strongly suggests that dysplastic nevi are precursor lesions that, with additional genetic damage, can trigger melanoma," said Tucker.
* The study is titled, "Clinically Recognized Dysplastic Nevi: A Central Risk Factor for Cutaneous Melanoma." The authors are Margaret A. Tucker, Allan Halpern, Elizabeth A. Holly, Patricia Hartge, David E. Elder, Richard W. Sagebiel, DuPont Guerry IV, and Wallace H. Clark, Jr. JAMA, May 14, 1997.
Cancer Information Service
The Cancer Information Service (CIS), a national information and education network, is a free public service of the National Cancer Institute (NCI), the federal government's primary agency for cancer research. The CIS meets the information needs of patients, the public, and health professionals. Specially trained staff provide the latest scientific information in understandable language. CIS staff answer questions in English and Spanish and distribute NCI materials.
For NCI information by fax, dial 301-402-5874 from the telephone on a fax machine and listen to
For NCI information by computer:
CancerNet Mail Service (via E-mail):
To obtain a contents list, send E-mail to email@example.com with the word
"help" in the body of the message.
Information is also accessible via the Internet through the World Wide Web at
(http://cancernet.nci.nih.gov) and Gopher (gopher://gopher.nih.gov) servers.