Skip to main content
  • U.S. Department of Health & Human Services
National Institutes of Health (NIH) - Turning Discovery into Health
  • Virtual Tour
  • En Español

Site Menu

  • Home
  • Health Information
    • Health Care Providers & Facilities
    • Health Info Lines
    • HealthCare.gov
    • Science Education Resources
    • NIH Clinical Research Trials and You
    • Talking to Your Doctor

    More »

    Quick Links

    • MedlinePlus Health Info
    • NIH News in Health
    • Wellness Toolkits
  • Grants & Funding
    • Grants Home Page
    • Find Funding
    • Due Dates
    • How to Apply
    • About Grants
    • Policy & Compliance
    • Grants News/Blog
    • Contracts
    • Loan Repayment

    More »

    Quick Links

    • RePORT
    • eRA Commons
    • NIH Common Fund
  • News & Events
    • News Releases
    • Digital Media Kits
    • Media Resources
    • Media Contacts
    • Images and B-roll
    • Events
    • Social Media

    More »

    Quick Links

    • NIH News in Health
    • NIH Research Matters
    • NIH Record
  • Research & Training
    • Medical Research Initiatives
    • Science Highlights
    • Science Education
    • Research in NIH Labs & Clinics
    • Training Opportunities
    • Library Resources
    • Research Resources
    • Clinical Research Resources
    • Safety, Regulation and Guidance

    More »

    Quick Links

    • PubMed
    • Stem Cell Information
    • OppNet
    • NIDB
    • NIH Blueprint for Neuroscience Research
  • Institutes at NIH
    • List of Institutes and Centers
    • NIH Office of the Director
    • Directors of NIH Institutes and Centers
    • NIH Institute and Center Contact Information

    More »

    Quick Links

    • NCI
    • NEI
    • NHLBI
    • NHGRI
    • NIA
    • NIAAA
    • NIAID
    • NIAMS
    • NIBIB
    • NICHD
    • NIDCD
    • NIDCR
    • NIDDK
    • NIDA
    • NIEHS
    • NIGMS
    • NIMH
    • NIMHD
    • NINDS
    • NINR
    • NLM
    • CC
    • CIT
    • CSR
    • FIC
    • NCATS
    • NCCIH
  • About NIH
    • Who We Are
    • What We Do
    • Jobs at NIH
    • Visitor Information
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Contact Us

    More »

    Quick Links

    • The NIH Director
    • Take the Virtual Tour
    • NIH…Turning Discovery Into Health®
    • Impact of NIH Research
    • Science, Health, and Public Trust

You are here

Home » About NIH » What We Do » Science, Health, and Public Trust

Science, Health, and Public Trust

Science, Health, and Public Trust

  • Submit a Suggestion

April 27, 2022

Putting Cancer Screening in Perspective

Doctor meeting a patient in the office and giving a medical consultation, he is using a digital tablet and checking medical records Stokkete / Shutterstock

By Paul Pinsky, Ph.D., Chief, Early Detection Research Group, NCI Division of Cancer Prevention; Philip Castle, Ph.D., M.P.H., Director, NCI Division of Cancer Prevention; Maureen Johnson, Ph.D., Executive Secretary, President’s Cancer Panel; and Samantha Finstad, Ph.D., Senior Health Science Policy Advisor, President’s Cancer Panel

It’s common wisdom that “catching the cancer early” is always a good thing. It can be a key factor in being able to survive cancer. You often hear, “luckily, they caught it early,” or the converse, “unfortunately, they didn’t detect it until it had spread” when people talk about friends or relatives with a cancer diagnosis. But the reality of cancer screening is not that simple.

The overall goal of cancer screening is to reduce cancer morbidity (illness) and mortality (death). There is no question that appropriate screening reduces illnesses and deaths due to cancer. Cervical and colorectal cancer incidence has declined in the last few decades by about 55% and 45%, respectively. Death rates have declined even more. These have been due primarily to routine screening.

Some types of screenings can detect cancer early (e.g., mammography for breast cancer and low-dose CT for lung cancer). Others can detect cancer early as well as detect cancer precursors, which can prompt action to prevent the development of cancer (e.g., colonoscopy screening for colorectal cancer and Pap smears and/or HPV testing for cervical cancer). Preventing cancer, even a curable cancer, is a large benefit in itself because it can reduce the many burdens to patients associated with a cancer diagnosis. 

But when communicating information about cancer screenings to the public, it’s important to discuss the benefits and the risks. Cancer screening will not necessarily benefit every patient who gets it. A patient could still succumb to cancer despite it being detected early. Others may survive even if their cancer was missed early on and caught at a later stage. And for some patients, screening can actually cause harms.

Screening may lead to the overdiagnosis of indolent (symptomless) cancers. These are cancers detected through screening that would never have become symptomatic in the patient’s lifetime. There is evidence of overdiagnosis associated with various types of screening, most notably PSA screening for prostate cancer. Overdiagnosis of cancer can lead to treatment, or overtreatment, and have serious side effects. For example, impotence and urinary incontinence are associated with prostate cancer surgery.

Screening can also lead to false positives—when people get a positive screening test but no cancer is found. Since screening tests are usually given to healthy people with a low risk of harboring cancer, the tests need to have a high specificity, or the ability to avoid too many false-positive results. A false-positive result can cause anxiety, require additional clinical visits and diagnostic procedures like imaging and biopsies, and lead to high costs for both the medical system and patient. For example, for mammography screening, around 8−12% of women will receive a false positive result at any given screening visit, and up to 45% will receive at least one false positive result over a ten year period of regular screening.

Since cancer screening is intended for those who have no signs or symptoms of cancer, it is important that the benefits strongly outweigh the risks. Cancer screening guidelines can change as new research shows which populations would benefit most from screening with the least harm. For example, more people became eligible for lung cancer screening in 2021, when the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force updated their eligibility recommendations, lowering the minimum age and the amount a person has smoked over their lifetime (or smoking pack-years).

For new screening approaches, establishing the high sensitivity of a test—the ability to find someone who does have cancer—is an important first step in determining its clinical utility. But it is only a first step. Researchers must also demonstrate that the benefits outweigh the harms. Such evidence generally requires a randomized clinical trial in which subjects are randomized to a screening and control arm. The primary outcome is typically mortality from the cancer in question. 

There is much discussion lately about the new “multi-cancer early detection” (MCED) tests. Also called liquid biopsies, these are blood tests that can detect multiple different cancer types simultaneously. To date, there has been limited research on the clinical utility of such tests—in other words, if they actually reduce illness and death. As these tests develop, it’s crucial to keep in mind that a sensitive test does not necessarily indicate clinical utility, or that the benefits of MCED screening would outweigh the harms.

While the benefits of appropriate screening are undeniable, it is important to acknowledge that harms can also be associated with screening; more is not always better. When describing cancer screening, make sure to refer to the current guidelines and clarify that screening isn’t for everyone. It should be done only for the right people at the right time.

Subscribe

Connect with Us

  • Contact Us
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • Flickr
  • More Social Media from NIH

Footer

  • NIH Home
  • Virtual Tour
  • En Español
  • Visitor Information
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimers
  • Accessibility
  • NIH Website Archives
  • Nondiscrimination Notice
  • Freedom of Information Act
  • No Fear Act
  • HHS Vulnerability Disclosure
  • Office of Inspector General
  • USA.gov

NIH…Turning Discovery Into Health®

National Institutes of Health, 9000 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, Maryland 20892

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Back to Top